diff --git a/twe/_simul.php b/twe/_simul.php
index 2ec1a276..62611eb1 100644
--- a/twe/_simul.php
+++ b/twe/_simul.php
@@ -250,7 +250,7 @@ if($isgen == "장수공격" || $isgen == "성벽공격" || $isgen == "장수평
 
                     //크리
                     $rd = rand() % 100; // 0 ~ 99
-                    $ratio = CriticalRatio2($general['leader'], $general['power'], $general['intel']);
+                    $ratio = CriticalRatio3($general['leader'], $general['power'], $general['intel']);
                     if($ratio >= $rd && $avoid == 1) {
                         $msg .= "<C>●</><C>필살</>공격!</><br>";
                         $cityCrew = CriticalScore2($cityCrew);
@@ -606,7 +606,7 @@ if($isgen == "장수공격" || $isgen == "성벽공격" || $isgen == "장수평
 
                     //크리
                     $rd = rand() % 100; // 0 ~ 99
-                    $ratio = CriticalRatio2($general['leader'], $general['power'], $general['intel']);
+                    $ratio = CriticalRatio3($general['leader'], $general['power'], $general['intel']);
                     if($ratio >= $rd && $myAvoid == 1) {
                         $msg .= "<C>●</><C>필살</>공격!</><br>";
                         $opCrew = CriticalScore2($opCrew);
@@ -614,7 +614,7 @@ if($isgen == "장수공격" || $isgen == "성벽공격" || $isgen == "장수평
                     }
                     //크리
                     $rd = rand() % 100; // 0 ~ 99
-                    $ratio = CriticalRatio2($oppose['leader'], $oppose['power'], $oppose['intel']);
+                    $ratio = CriticalRatio3($oppose['leader'], $oppose['power'], $oppose['intel']);
                     if($ratio >= $rd && $opAvoid == 1) {
                         $msg .= "<C>●</>상대의 <R>필살</>공격!</><br>";
                         $myCrew = CriticalScore2($myCrew);
diff --git a/twe/process_war.php b/twe/process_war.php
index 905a145f..2b172074 100644
--- a/twe/process_war.php
+++ b/twe/process_war.php
@@ -273,7 +273,7 @@ function processWar($connect, $general, $city) {
 
                 //크리
                 $rd = rand() % 100; // 0 ~ 99
-                $ratio = CriticalRatio2($general['leader']+getHorseEff($general['horse'])+$lbonus, $general['power']+getWeapEff($general['weap']), $general['intel']+getBookEff($general['book']));
+                $ratio = CriticalRatio3($general['leader']+getHorseEff($general['horse'])+$lbonus, $general['power']+getWeapEff($general['weap']), $general['intel']+getBookEff($general['book']));
                 // 특기보정 : 무쌍, 필살
                 if($general['special2'] == 61) { $ratio += 10; }
                 if($general['special2'] == 71) { $ratio += 20; }
@@ -1030,7 +1030,7 @@ function processWar($connect, $general, $city) {
 
                 //크리
                 $rd = rand() % 100; // 0 ~ 99
-                $ratio = CriticalRatio2($general['leader']+getHorseEff($general['horse'])+$lbonus, $general['power']+getWeapEff($general['weap']), $general['intel']+getBookEff($general['book']));
+                $ratio = CriticalRatio3($general['leader']+getHorseEff($general['horse'])+$lbonus, $general['power']+getWeapEff($general['weap']), $general['intel']+getBookEff($general['book']));
                 // 특기보정 : 무쌍, 필살
                 if($general['special2'] == 61) { $ratio += 10; }
                 if($general['special2'] == 71) { $ratio += 20; }
@@ -1052,7 +1052,7 @@ function processWar($connect, $general, $city) {
                 }
                 //크리
                 $rd = rand() % 100; // 0 ~ 99
-                $ratio = CriticalRatio2($oppose['leader']+getHorseEff($oppose['horse'])+$opplbonus, $oppose['power']+getWeapEff($oppose['weap']), $oppose['intel']+getBookEff($oppose['book']));
+                $ratio = CriticalRatio3($oppose['leader']+getHorseEff($oppose['horse'])+$opplbonus, $oppose['power']+getWeapEff($oppose['weap']), $oppose['intel']+getBookEff($oppose['book']));
                 // 특기보정 : 필살
                 if($oppose['special2'] == 71) { $ratio += 20; }
                 if($ratio >= $rd && $opAvoid == 1) {
@@ -1436,6 +1436,10 @@ function processWar($connect, $general, $city) {
     return $deadAmount;
 }
 
+function CriticalRatio3($leader, $power, $intel) {
+    return 15; //15% 고정
+}
+
 function CriticalRatio2($leader, $power, $intel) {
     // 707010장수 9% 706515장수 17% 706020장수 25% xx50xx장수 57%
     if($leader <= $power && $leader <= $intel) {        // 통솔이 제일 낮은경우